Another Place

Essay published in Another Place, Autumn 2025

Experiences of both west Wales and Cornwall during the
five years covered here proved transformative, although their
impact on me was not necessarily immediate or obvious.
During this time, I moved between these places when our
home was in the Valleys of southeast Wales. Later reflections
on my experiences at the doppelgänger places of west Wales
and Cornwall led me to refer to my collective experiences of
them as being akin to pilgrimage and exile.

Perhaps these terms are appropriate as during what has been
called the Dark Ages Christian missionaries travelled
between these two western peninsulas spreading their beliefs.
There are church dedications in both west Wales and
Cornwall for St. Pedrog (Petroc), St Meugan (Mawgan), St.
Gwbert, St Carranog, St. Briog, and others. The churches
are usually within a short distance of the respective
coastlines suggesting that the connecting westerly sea routes
were preferred over travel along eastern land routes that at
the time were subject to Anglo-Saxon invasions. On starting
a new job in Cornwall in 2015, my preferred route of travel
was the M4/M5 motorway, usually once every two weeks
and often very early in the morning to miss heavy tourist
traffic. The occasional journeys in the other direction along
the M4 at that time took me to west Wales.

Truro Cathedral introduces visitors to the idea that Cornwall
is the Land of the Saints. A graphic poster provides an
inspiring vision as seen from above Cornwall looking
downwards with the tip of the peninsula fading in the
distance. Floating above a glowing panorama of land and
sea a multitude of saints file along wisps of golden cloud
with a majestic beam of holy light emanating from the host
falling below to illuminate the cathedral itself. Lesser beams
highlight the many church locations dedicated to the saints
of Cornwall.

It took a while for the intensity of starting a new job to
subside but gradually more time became available to
consider this new place. Of course, the word ‘place’ is not as
simple as it seems, it can be a complex concept in that the
relationship we have to a particular place is understood as
unique and irreducible. That is, you can be located at a
specific spot on a street, at the seaside, in a village and so on,
yet for it to be a place (rather than just a location) you bring
to it your experience and knowledge thus giving it meaning
and value. Sometimes meaning and value is collectively
created – a cultural value that develops through shared
experiences and history. It is perhaps no surprise that as I sat
in our apartment looking out at Baya an Garrek (Mounts
Bay) watching the occasional passing boat or ship, my
thoughts would turn to those early missionaries and the
stories told about them. It should be added that there is
historical evidence of those monks having travelled together.
For the most part, I was a commuting migrant worker
travelling alone.

West Wales had been a regular destination for us from the
mid-1990s. There were no connections with the place as
such, other than the knowledge that my grandmother’s
grandfather once lived in Carmarthenshire and had worked
on a farm near Llanboidy. He was one of the many west-
Walians to take the long trek to the burgeoning industrial
valleys in the nineteenth century to find himself a better life.
Over a hundred years later our motivation for going to west
Wales was to enjoy short leisure breaks away from work and
the Valleys.

West Wales can feel like another country in comparison to
the Valleys. The largely rural landscape eventually
surrenders itself to the dramatic rocky coastline and the sea.
More Cymraeg is spoken, and English is heard in a wider
variety of dialects carried by the many tourists from the
Midlands, Yorkshire, London and elsewhere. The well-
stocked shops are smaller, and public transport is lesser in
scale and rarely offers full or frequent coverage across what
is at times remote terrain. There are more B&Bs, tea rooms
and campsites – all of which take on a haunting quality
outside the holiday season. The history appears deeper than
the industrial experience that has most often defined the
Valleys. Tales from Taliesin, the Mabinogion and the Celtic
saints increasingly inhabit your being not only through
reading their associated literature, but also by walking
through the land in which their stories unfold.

My main experience of Cornwall began some twenty years
after I had first started to regularly visit west Wales. At first
it seemed quite bizarre to find that, to a large extent,
Cornwall was like west Wales and west Wales was like
Cornwall. Both occupy a western peninsula poking into an
often stormy Atlantic with the same types of rocky coastline
interspersed with beautiful sandy beaches. They have
similar craggy moors, ancient megaliths and pastoral lands
that have been farmed for millennia. Each has a distinct yet
closely connected language; Wales has Cymraeg, Cornwall
has Kernewek. Hosted by Gorsedh Kernow, the Esedhvos
Festival offers the equivalent of the Welsh Eisteddfod, itself
understood to have been established at Cardigan Castle in
1176 to host competitions in poetry and music. Such
similarities can suggest a real sense of equivalence; but
there are other resemblances that invoke a more unsettling
feeling, something strangely familiar, something uncanny. I
realise now that at the time I was starting to think
differently about where I belonged.

This is where a lifetime living and working in the Valleys of
south Wales subverts the neat comparisons made above.
Whilst west Wales seemed like another country to someone
whose life had been invested in the Valleys, there are many
obvious connections between these two regions of Wales
through shared linguistics, history and culture. Of course,
what was (and is) shared was radically challenged by the
rapid industrialisation of south Wales, and I realise that in
making the comparisons I have so far made between west
Wales and Cornwall I could be guilty of ‘romantic
prejudice’ by over-emphasising pre-industrial aspects of
these places. It could be said that my experiences of the
uncanny were as much to do with industrial/post-industrial
aspects of these places as anything else. Put simply, the
photographs in this collection are in many ways a response
to three places: west Wales, Cornwall and the Valleys.

For example, almost every day I spent in Cornwall I would
travel past the remnants of its tin mining industry – the pit
head and engine house looked very different to those seen
in the coal mining Valleys. My response to these redundant
Cornish mines were at one and the same time a form of
vague recognition and visceral estrangement. Similar
feelings were generated in relation to the many non-
Conformist chapels I would see. As in Wales, they
flourished during the industrial period, were most often
built to similar designs and given the same biblical names.
There was however something missing; those Welsh words
literally set in stone on the front of chapels that I had
always taken for granted in Wales were nowhere to be seen;
Annibynwyr had been replaced by ‘Independents’, etc.
Knowing that in these places I was unlikely to hear hymns
such as Calon Lan, Cwm Rhondda or Myfanwy felt
strangely unsettling, yet it is the case that the Cornish
choral tradition is often compared to that of Wales for its
excellence and emotional power. The brass band traditions
are often similarly compared. Perhaps the starkest
counterpoint of all are the dominant spoil heaps on the top
of the hills which due to clay extraction are white and not
black. To my eyes, Cornwall was a strange land of familiar
places that had been given some strange ability to shape-
shift.

This collection of black and white photographs was taken
during a period of several years while I was living at home
in southeast Wales and experiencing these two other places
that were similar yet distinctly different to each other.
There were clear historical and cultural connections
between them which were familiar to me, at times that
familiarity could be strange, uncanny and deeply
unsettling.

ANOTHER PLACE
Another Place presents photographs made without any apparent purpose - not part of some conscious schema. Taken in west Wales and Cornwall between 2013 and 2018, each photograph was an immediate response to a particular place at a particular time. Brought together for the first time several years later, they reveal a story of place, dislocation and longing.

Includes photographs and essays relating to the making of photographs in west Wales and Cornwall.

60 pp / 226 x 170mm
Softback, matt cover
150gsm Recycled Silk paper
Edition of 50
Tirnod Press
ISBN 978-1-9163896-2-5